Visit to Paris, France under the PIPA program by Dr. Ong Kian Ming, MP for Serdang, from the 29th of June to the 4th of July, 2015

I was invited by the French embassy in Kuala Lumpur to take part in an Invitation Program for Future Leaders (Programme d’invitation des personnalités d’avenir) from the 29th of June to the 4th of July, 2015. The following is a report of some of the key takeaway points from my program. I have omitted the names of the individuals I had official meetings with, but have included the institutions to which they are attached to. These takeaway points are the main lessons which left an impression with me, as a result of my visit.

Key takeaway points

1) Institutional reform in the National Assembly and the Senate

In my visits to the National Assembly (lower house) and the Senate and in my discussions with various individuals, I found that that there has been significant reforms in the legislative process on July 23, 2008. These reforms were part of a larger constitutional reform, the most significant since it was drawn up in 1958[1]. These legislative reforms include:

  • Allowing parliament to set the legislative agenda for half the time when parliament is sitting, rather than allowing only the executive to set the entire agenda
  • The recognition in the Constitution of political groups comprising of individual MPs, which can introduce and amend legislative bills
  • The recognition of the rights for the opposition and minority groups including the setting aside of one day during each sitting to propose legislative agenda, holding the chairmanship of the Finance Committee and the ad-hoc committee in charge of checking, and auditing the accounts of the National Assembly and the right to request for a Commission of Inquiry during a sitting, just to name a few.[2]

The effect of these legislative changes was to empower parliament, parliamentary committees and opposition groups in parliament, so that it can play a more effective check and balance role on the executive. There are many legislative reforms from the 2008 constitutional amendment which can be examined by the Malaysian parliament, especially now that the speaker of the Dewan Rakyat in Malaysia has announced his intention to introduce significant legislative reforms in the near future.[3]

2) The relationship between the legislative process and the EU

There is a special parliamentary group overseeing European Affairs which has to examine the impact of EU legislation on French laws. The briefing I was given by one of the ‘clerks’, who is one of the civil servants who provides the relevant information regarding EU legislation to French MPs, was very helpful in giving me a general idea on how the relationship between the EU and the French legislature is managed. The team of research ‘clerks’ would categorize various EU laws according to their level of importance and priority, so that the MPs could focus only on the most important laws. Of course, some MPs would sometimes question the prioritization choices but on the whole, it seemed to me that the experience of the research ‘clerks’ allow them to accurately categorize most of the EU legislation. There would be a natural gravitation of certain lawmakers towards certain topics and because of the relationship between the research ‘clerks’ and members of the European Affairs committee, the ‘clerks’ would often know which EU law to highlight to which legislators.

This briefing also highlighted to me the importance of the research ‘clerks’ in analysing and filtering the relevant EU legislation for presentation to the MPs.

3) The lack of awareness and knowledge among MPs on Malaysia and South-East Asia

I met an MP from the National Assembly or the lower house who was listed as the head of the France-Malaysia parliamentary friendship group. She was very friendly and provided a useful picture on the semi-urban constituency she represented and the challenges her voters faced, including having to face global competition and industrial hollowing out. But she told me that she had stepped down as the head of the France-Malaysia friendship group because she felt that the position ‘deserved someone better’. She had not been to Malaysia and the only reason why she was still listed as being the head of this group was because no one had replaced her.

I also met two other MPs from the Senate who are part of the France – South East Asia inter-parliamentary group. One of the Senators had recently visited Malaysia and the other had not. Again, they did not display much knowledge or interest on Malaysian related issues.

It is not surprising that the level of knowledge and interest in Malaysia among French MPs is low, since Malaysia is a small country and was not a former French colony. Perhaps, the Malaysian embassy in Paris needs to do more to promote French-Malaysia ties among the relevant French MPs in the National Assembly and in the Senate.

4) Changes in Regional and Local Autonomy

Through my conversations with various politicians and other individuals, I got the impression that the regional as well as local (at the department level) governments have significant autonomy over policy, as well as budgetary issues including infrastructure spending and education.

There is obviously some inequality between government spending in the more affluent versus the less affluent areas. For example, a municipal councillor in Saint Denis, a municipality just outside Paris with a large immigrant population, complained that the spending on education and policing is much lower than in central Paris.

I also found out that the 22 regional governments are in the process of being reorganized in 14 regions.[4] The rationale behind this was the reduce bureaucracy and red tape and save money in administrative expenditure.[5] Not surprisingly, these reforms have received their fair share of criticisms and are unpopular in certain regions, because of the prospect of losing the status of regional capitals and identities.[6] At the same time 10 new city regions will have public services created and spending redistributed.[7] For example, the above mentioned Saint-Denis will be included as part of the Grand Paris super-metropole, which hopefully will decrease some of the imbalances in public services that currently exist in the larger Paris metropolitan area.

5) The influence of think tanks and their relationship with the government and political parties

I had the opportunity to meet with academics and representatives from various think tanks and research units in universities. I found that there is a close relationship between academics in these organizations and policy makers in the government. Not surprisingly, this arrangement has its pros and cons. On the one hand, it can be very useful for academics with good ideas and policy proposals to be able to channel these ideas to policy makers in the government, so that they can be considered for implementation. For example, one academic I met had a very fascinating proposal to allow the private banks to buy up credits for green investment schemes which would be guaranteed directly by central banks and possibly the European Central Bank (ECB). This proposal was a win-win in that it allows for investment and avoids the liquidity trap and at the same time, helps the government meet its goals for reducing carbon emissions and promote environmental sustainability. The academic was attached to the Center d’Etudes Prospectives et d’Informations Internationales (CEPII)[8] and he was working closely with France Strategie[9], a policy think tank under the Prime Minister’s Office. The proposal can be read here[10] and France Strategie is advocating this proposal through seminars like this.[11]

On the other hand, the close relationship between the government and think tanks may restrict research projects, especially those which may harm the relationship between the French government and other countries.

Unlike the German system where each major party has their own think tanks which are publicly funded as a result of their links to the respective parties, not all French parties have their own think tanks. The Jean Jaures Foundation is the one which is most closely associated with a political party – the Socialist Party. It receives most of its rather limited funding from the state and some from private sources, but none from the party so that it can maintain its independence.[12] The Jean Jaures Foundation has some policy influence through its ties with MPs via the party. It also does public advocacy on issues such as climate change and international cooperation, mostly in the former French colonies.

Of course, international organizations which are based in Paris such as UNESCO and the OECD are independent bodies of which France is only one member country among many. I found my meeting with OECD representatives especially interesting from the point of view that it is a think tank which does extensive and internationally acknowledged research on a number of topics such as education, investment and trade, but who is also answerable to a council made up of representatives of all the OECD member countries which may have slightly different views in regards to the objectives of the OECD. The OECD has recently increased its interactions with South East Asia governments, including the setting up of a small office in Jakarta. It seems likely the level of interaction will only grow over time, perhaps with the admission of its first South East Asian member country.

6) The economics of the EU, Greece and the Euro

I expressed my interest in learning more about EU economic policy especially in regards to the Eurozone and to Greece to the French embassy in KL prior to my departure. Little did I know that the “Grexit” issue would take such great prominence during my visit to Paris. In my discussion with different economists, I found the following points of agreement with some individual nuances:

  • That Greece needs to have some or all of its debt forgiven by the European countries if it is to have any chance to get out of its current economic predicament. The nuances would involve the process by which the debt is forgiven / written off and the conditions attached to this. Some economists think that that the Germans are overly rigid in its rules based approach towards its negotiations with Greece.
  • That it would probably be better for Greece to exit the Eurozone and default on its debt obligations if it cannot find a way to reduce the overall debt burden.
  • That the Greek economy is very uncompetitive and tremendously reliant on tourism and to a lesser extent, olive oil. There was a consistent level of disdain towards the Greek economy and a general feeling that the current situation which Greece finds itself in was created by bad government policies and corrupt and compromised governments.

7) Minorities in France, especially Muslims

One of the biggest challenges facing the French nation is the issue of how to ‘manage’ or deal with minority groups, including Jews and the Romas but especially the large and growing Arab / Muslim population (Not all Arabs in France are Muslims but a majority of them are).

France has been and continues to experience a large emigration of its Jewish population to Israel, possibly as a result of high profile terrorist attacks against the community.[13] This predates the attacks on the Charlie Hebdo office in January of this year. This trend continues despite the attempts of the French government to protect the Jewish community from further attacks. I was told that Jewish synagogues and schools are constantly under surveillance by the French security services for their protection. A personal story which was related to me by Jewish activist working against Anti-Semitism was his experience of going to his synagogue and finding three French soldiers sleeping in there because they were taking a break from their duties. He found this comforting as well as disconcerting, because he felt that he should not be living in a country where synagogues needed such a level of protection.

I also found out that France has a small but significant population of Romas (or the Romani people) – as many as 500,000 – many of whom are fully integrated into French society. I had not realized this before, since my impression of the Romas were that they were nomadic peoples and mostly found in big cities in Europe seeking out a living as scrapers and pickpockets – but there are actually different groups of Romas with origins from Germany, Italy and Spain.[14] The Romas who are nomadic only number 20,000 but they have received a lot of publicity over the past two years because of their clashes with the French government.[15]

The Roma activist whom I met who is from Albania (and not a French citizen) had many interesting viewpoints on how to advocate for the rights of the community. For example, he said that activists for minority groups in France should not adopt a victimhood mentality and also minimize dialogues which he found to be ineffective. He preferred action over dialogue and viewed the admission of past guilt by the French authorities with slight disdain, as this would give an excuse to the authorities to say that they have done enough for minority groups while ignoring current transgresses. When I asked him if he would support a move by the French government to establish a Holocaust-like museum for the Romas who were exterminated during the Second World War, he replied that he was lukewarm towards the idea. One take away point from this conversation is not to refer to Romas as gypsies, as this was considered as a pejorative.

The biggest challenge for the French authorities continues to be how to deal with the Arab and especially the Arab-Muslim population. The French concept of the state as being secular and being encapsulated in the concept of Laïcité is currently being challenged most strongly by the Muslim community over issues such as the wearing of the Muslim headscarf or hijab in public, the eating of halal food in public schools and praying on the streets during Friday prayers, just to name a few. The fact that many Arab-Muslims live in economically backward and dilapidated suburbs or ‘banlieues’ on the fringes of major French cities only further complicates the challenge of ‘managing’ this community.[16] The disturbing development of many young French men (and some women) joining the IS (or ‘daesh’[17] as it is called in France) also further complicates the dealings of the French state with its Muslim population.

The French authorities do not want to be criticized for either privileging the Muslim community nor do they want to be seen as targeting the Muslim community. The Muslim community feels marginalized since they feel that there is a larger phenomenon of Islamaphobia which exists in society and in institutions, which is made worse by the fact that the government does not admit to the existence of such a phenomenon. The Muslims can’t help but feel that some laws have been enacted to target them using the concept of laicite as a smokescreen, such as the banning of the display of religious symbols in schools and the prohibition against wearing the face veil in public.[18] From my discussions with various individuals including a representative from the Collectif Contre L’Islamophobie En France (CCIF)[19], it is very likely that the tensions between the state and the Muslim community will continue to simmer.

It is also likely that the Muslim community will form more Muslim NGOs in order to mobilize support for its causes, such as battling Islamaphobia and other community advocacy initiatives. CCIF, for example, collects and then investigates reports of discriminatory attacks and actions against Muslim individuals[20] and then publishes the results of their investigations.[21]

The French authorities do seem to be acknowledging the need to do more outreach to the Muslim community, including having regular dialogues between the Minister of the Interior and representatives from the Muslim community including those who are not from the officially recognized French Muslim Council[22] which has a legitimacy problem in the eyes of some French Muslims. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs also has a special ambassador who is in charge of dealing with religious affairs, which includes issues within and outside France which have a religious dimension to them. In my conservation with the ambassador, he acknowledges that the Muslim world, especially near to France in the Middle East and Northern Africa are his key priorities for now.

One particularly interesting conversation I had was with a municipal councilor in Saint Denis, who is in charge of anti-discrimination policy. He is a French-born Muslim with parents or grandparents from North Africa who is a strong supporter of Palestine. He represents the Left Front[23] who sits on the left of the Socialists. At the same time, he is also a strong supporter of the LGBT movement. In his opinion, Muslims in France should not support policies which discriminate against any group including LGBTs, even though they may not agree with their lifestyle choices. He noted that even though some Muslim groups had initially joined anti-LGBT protests by far right groups, most Muslims groups would refrain from joining such protests in the future.

8) Urban regeneration

I specially asked to visit the Stade-de-France which is located in Saint Denis, to see if the development of the stadium in an economically depressed area just outside Paris had brought about long-term development and urban regeneration 17 years after the staging of the 1998 World Cup.

What I saw was indeed encouraging. The upgrading of the Canal Saint-Denis, in conjunction with the development of the Stade-De-France, which has become a tourist attraction and used by many for recreational purposes, is arguably one of success stories of urban regeneration.[24] There is a public cycling / jogging path of 6.6km on both sides of the canal which leads all the way up to the famous Saint Denis Basilica[25], located in the heart of Saint Denis town, that was the burial place for the Kings and Queens of France. When I visited the Basilica, it was being prepped for the Saint Denis Festival featuring a symphony orchestra.[26] The festival predates the World Cup – it started in 1970 – but I can’t help feel that some of the positive ‘vibes’ surrounding the Stade-de-France had also filtered into the town of Saint Denis. While there are still some pockets of poverty around the town area, I could see a very diverse crowd in the town center which had a street market, busy restaurants and small shops.

As a result of the construction of Stade-de-France, a large highway from Saint Denis to Paris called A1 was converted and this added new and valuable real estate to the area. Much of this was converted into public parks and many neighbourhoods which were previously separated by the A1 highway were reunited, with positive results.

On the whole, one would say that the building of the Stade-De-France has been a success story in terms of urban regeneration for the Saint Denis area.[27]

9) Paris COP 21

There was great awareness of the Paris COP 21 summit on climate change, which will be taking place in November and early December this year. There were also many signboards and public advertisements promoting Paris COP 21.

Unfortunately, because I had not indicated my interest in environmental issues, I was not able to arrange for specific meetings with the relevant experts to discuss the details of Paris COP 21.

10) The experience of Paris

Finally, one cannot go to Paris without experiencing the sights and sounds of Paris. I had the pleasure of running along the Seine on the Left and Right Bank and seeing the many famous landmarks in the heart of Paris. I also managed to visit the Picasso museum which had been recently renovated. I had dinner and drinks with a Singaporean academic who was also on the PIPA program. I met up with a Malaysian friend for dinner and she introduced me to other academics who are interested in Malaysian / South East Asian issues. I had dinner with a French academic whom I knew from her research visits to Malaysia, and her husband was kind enough to give me a ride back to my hotel in his scooter. So I can say that I saw Paris in a car, on foot, on a train and on a scooter. Sadly, I didn’t manage to rent a bicycle to cycle through Paris because of the unseasonable heat wave that hit Paris during my visit. The accessibility of Paris as a city really struck me as a visitor.

I even managed to squeeze in some time to buy some Belgian chocolates from my friends and family back home.

Finally, my visit would not have been so memorable without the assistance of three people – Marie-Pierre Levert, the person at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in charge of my program, John Ritchie, my interpreter and chaperone, and my driver, Patrick Gagnaut.

It was a fantastic learning experience and one which I will not forget for a long time to come.

Some pictures from my visit

Running along the Seine and around the Louvre in the morning

With two Senators at the Senate building, Jardin du Luxembourg

Bicycles for public rental

With activists fighting for minority rights

With Paul, my driver, and John, my interpreter, at Stade-de-France

From the Picasso Museum


[2] These changes can be found in the document entitled: “The National Assembly in the French Institutions”. The pdf file in English can be found here: The latest version has been updated to November 2014.














[16] Of course, there are various communities within the larger Arab-Muslim community with those from Tunisia and Algeria being the largest.










[26] and